Stablecoin issuers froze about 44% of the money stolen in the Binance hack, according to blockchain analytics firm Elliptic, which leaves more than half of the largest crypto theft on record outside anyone’s reach. Binance puts the damage at $6.3 billion, and CNBC reported that $6.3 billion in assets were impacted at the world’s largest crypto exchange, with Bitcoin sliding below $78,000 and Circle shares dropping more than 5% in early trading.
The Washington Post called it likely the biggest crypto theft ever. Elliptic and TRM Labs both size it at roughly four times the Bybit heist of February 2025, which we broke down against Binance’s numbers earlier this week. What has changed since then is the recovery picture. Tether, Circle and a handful of smaller issuers moved fast, and that response now sets the ceiling on what victims can get back.
This analysis focuses on the freeze response: who froze what, how quickly, how the trackers disagree, and what the roughly $3.6 billion that slipped through means for markets, regulators and exchange security teams. It also separates what outlets have confirmed from what remains guesswork, because the attribution and root cause are still open.
What Happened in the Binance Hack on Oct. 29
Elliptic dates the theft to Oct. 29, 2026, and puts the first wave between about 20:05 and 20:50 UTC. A second wave started around 23:00 UTC. TRM Labs reached a similar picture, with the majority of funds leaving within roughly 20 minutes of the 20:05 UTC start and a secondary push at 23:05 UTC. CNBC places the event in the early hours of Oct. 30, which lines up once you account for time zones.
The attacker prepared well ahead of time. TRM Labs reports that staging began at least 36 hours earlier, with small Tornado Cash withdrawals on Oct. 28. That pattern matches earlier North Korean thefts, in TRM’s assessment. CNBC, citing investigation findings, says the initial entry point was a compromised laptop belonging to a DevOps engineer. We covered that detail in our report on the DevOps laptop and the first $3 billion freeze.
| Time (UTC) | Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Oct. 28 | Small Tornado Cash withdrawals begin staging, 36+ hours before the theft | TRM Labs |
| Oct. 29, ~20:05 | First wave starts across multiple blockchains | Elliptic, TRM Labs |
| Oct. 29, ~20:20 | Ethereum sweeps begin using pre-signed authorizations | TRM Labs |
| Oct. 29, ~20:50 | First wave winds down | Elliptic |
| Oct. 29, ~23:00 to 23:05 | Second wave begins | Elliptic, TRM Labs |
| Oct. 29, ~23:56 | Last Ethereum sweep in TRM’s timeline | TRM Labs |
| Oct. 29 to 30 | Binance suspends deposits and withdrawals, says about $3B frozen | CNBC, Al Jazeera |
The sweep window is the key detail. A theft that stretches across roughly three hours on the clock but concentrates most of its value into 20 minutes gives defenders very little room to react. Our 20-minute developer lessons piece goes deeper on what that compressed timeline means for signing infrastructure.
The Numbers: What Was Taken and Where
The three main trackers disagree slightly on the total. Binance says $6.3 billion. TRM Labs counts $6.36 billion across 10 blockchains. Elliptic counts $6.43 billion across 11, depending on how it groups the Layer 2 networks. The gap is small against the scale of the loss, but it shows how early these tallies are. Where the figures differ, this article uses the lower number.
Ethereum carried the bulk. TRM puts roughly $3.79 billion there, including 200,630 ETH and 185 tokens, among them 1.875 billion USDT, 823 million USDC and 88.5 million RLUSD. Elliptic’s count is $3.80 billion across 186 tokens. Bitcoin follows at 18,270 BTC, worth about $1.47 billion to $1.48 billion in the two reports. Elliptic puts stablecoins at $3.46 billion of the total, which is why issuer cooperation matters so much.
| Blockchain | Approx. value stolen | Main assets |
|---|---|---|
| Ethereum | $3.79B | 200,630 ETH plus 185 tokens (USDT, USDC, RLUSD) |
| Bitcoin | $1.47B | 18,270 BTC |
| Tron | $628M | 612.7M USDT plus 46.4M TRX |
| XRP Ledger | $296M | 233.46M XRP |
| Solana | $96M | 970,500 SOL |
| Arbitrum, Optimism, Base | $39M | Includes 74.6M ARB |
| Avalanche | $28M | AVAX |
| Polygon | $10M | Mixed tokens |
Source: TRM Labs. Elliptic’s per-chain figures differ in places, and neither firm has published a final audit.
The Stablecoin Freeze Scoreboard
Elliptic verified $2.84 billion frozen, or 44% of the theft. TRM Labs counts about $2.7 billion. Binance told reporters it had frozen roughly $3 billion, and CNBC listed $800 million from Circle and $1.56 billion from Tether. These figures overlap and do not add up, because Binance’s number appears to include assets that issuers also froze. The safest reading is a range of $2.7 billion to $2.84 billion confirmed by independent trackers.
| Freezer | Elliptic | TRM Labs | CNBC |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tether (USDT) | 1.18B USDT | ~1.77B USDT | $1.56B |
| Circle (USDC) | 823M USDC | ~825M USDC | $800M |
| Ripple (RLUSD) | Named, not itemized | 40.5M of 88.5M taken | Not reported |
| World Liberty Financial (USD1) | Named, not itemized | 27.8M USD1 | Not reported |
| Arbitrum Security Council | Emergency asset move | 8,426 ETH plus 74.6M ARB (~$30M) | Not reported |
| Total confirmed | $2.84B (44%) | ~$2.7B | Binance cites ~$3B |
Tether and Circle: Minutes Mattered
Elliptic’s timeline shows Tether acting 37 minutes after the funds arrived and Circle freezing its USDC three minutes after that. Both moves came while the attacker was still working the second wave. Paxos and First Digital also appear among the issuers that froze stablecoins, and Binance froze its own WBETH tokens. The speed differences are small in absolute terms, yet every minute gave the attacker a chance to swap tokens into assets no issuer can touch.
Why the Unfrozen 56% Matters More Than the Frozen 44%
Subtract Elliptic’s frozen total from its theft total and about $3.59 billion remains unfrozen. That is our arithmetic, not a figure either firm published. TRM Labs gives a cleaner anchor: it estimates the attacker still controls roughly $2.4 billion, including more than 420,000 ETH and the 18,270 BTC. The difference between the two numbers reflects tokens already swapped, sold at a discount or lost to frozen lending markets.
Native assets such as ETH and BTC carry no issuer with a freeze switch. That puts recovery in the hands of exchanges, law enforcement and bridge operators. The Bitcoin stash is the sharpest example. Elliptic reports the 18,270 BTC sits in 19 addresses, mostly in 1,000 BTC lots, with none sent to a service yet. We tracked those wallets in our report on the 19-wallet Bitcoin parking pattern.
For Binance, the split matters for the balance sheet. The exchange has said it will cover every loss, so recovered funds reduce its own bill rather than flowing to customers directly. That framing is why the freeze count drew so much attention in the first 48 hours.
How the Attacker Moved the Rest
Both trackers describe an attacker who accepted steep losses to get out of frozen-prone assets. Elliptic reports that 434 million USDT was swapped for 160,451 ETH through Uniswap and 1inch at prices 12% to 26% below market. TRM Labs describes a similar sale of about 325 million USDT to market makers through UniswapX at a discount above 10%. Paying that haircut tells you the attacker valued speed over price.
DeFi lending provided another exit. Elliptic says 59.9 million USDT went into Aave, against which the attacker borrowed 19,762 ETH. TRM puts those figures at 60 million USDT and about 19,760 ETH and notes that the markets were later frozen. Elliptic also records 48 million RLUSD dumped, about 150 other tokens converted to ETH, and AVAX routed through Circle’s cross-chain transfer protocol into USDC and then 7,242.8 ETH. Our earlier report on the hunt for exit ramps and DeFi pauses covers how protocols responded.
Tron and Bitcoin: Slow and Split
On Tron, Elliptic reports 638 million TRX split across five addresses, with between $20 million and $36 million laundered so far through swap services and cross-chain bridges. TRM adds that the Bitcoin was cut into round pieces of 1,000 and 100 BTC, a classic peel-chain setup. Splitting that way makes later cash-out look like ordinary transfers, so watch for activity on those 19 addresses.
Attack Method: Pre-Signed Authorizations and EIP-7702
The technical picture remains partial. TRM Labs says the attacker submitted 50 pre-signed authorizations that used the EIP-7702 delegation feature on Ethereum to hand control of wallets to a sweeper contract. On the other nine chains, the transfers looked like ordinary signed transactions, which TRM reads as a sign that Binance’s hot wallet signing infrastructure was compromised. TRM labels that last point an assessment, not a proven fact.
According to Elliptic’s write-up, co-CEO Richard Teng said the attack involved more than one person and that the attacker used a self-destruct mechanism to erase tooling and traces as it ran. Binance also said the EIP-7702 delegation did not pass through its normal approval controls, and that it found additional breach points beyond the DevOps laptop. TRM notes Binance has not yet published a root-cause report.
The batch-signing detail stands out. Fifty authorizations suggest the attacker held access for a limited window, then cashed it in all at once. Teams that run hot wallets should treat that as a design lesson rather than a Binance-only problem.
North Korea Attribution: What Holds and What Does Not
Elliptic calls North Korea-linked actors the likely culprits, and TRM Labs names the TraderTraitor cluster. Their strongest evidence is financial. Elliptic confirmed that some of the Tron funds were laundered alongside proceeds from the September 2026 Bitget exploit, which it rates as highly likely tied to North Korea. TRM points to the Tornado Cash staging pattern, the 36-hour lead time and the pre-signed batch approach seen in the Bybit and KelpDAO cases.
Elliptic also lists reasons for caution. Only a small share of the Binance funds has mixed with Bitget proceeds so far. The stablecoin conversion ran slower than a typical North Korean operation. And no government has made an official attribution. The FBI named North Korea for the $1.5 billion Bybit hack within five days, according to Elliptic, and CNBC notes the same attribution. This time, two days in, there is no such statement.
Our analysis of North Korea’s 85% share of hack value shows why investigators start there. Starting there is still not proof, so treat the label as a working hypothesis.
Historical Context: From Iraq’s $1 Billion to Bybit’s $1.5 Billion
Elliptic describes the Binance theft as almost certainly the largest single theft of any kind in history, and it cites the 2003 removal of roughly $1 billion from the Central Bank of Iraq as the previous mark. In crypto specifically, the Bybit hack of February 2025 held the record at about $1.46 billion to $1.5 billion. Binance’s loss is about 4.2 to 4.4 times that, depending on whose estimate you use.
The pattern across those cases is consistent. Attackers go after the people and systems around the keys, not the cryptography. Bybit involved staff targeting and infrastructure compromise, and Elliptic sees similar traits here. The new element in the Binance case is the scale of the stablecoin freeze response, which had no real equivalent at Bybit’s size.
Market Impact: Bitcoin, Circle and the ETF Complex
CNBC reported that Bitcoin fell below $78,000 after the news, and that Circle shares dropped more than 5% in early trading. Crypto funds also declined, including the ProShares Bitcoin Strategy ETF and the iShares Bitcoin Trust. The Circle reaction is the interesting one. Circle did the right thing by freezing USDC, yet its stock still took the hit, which shows investors price in regulatory and operational risk around stablecoins.
Liquidity effects came next. Our report on the withdrawal pause and the reported $3.52 billion outflow tracks how customers reacted when the exchange halted deposits and withdrawals.
Binance’s Response and the Loss Pledge
Teng told users, per CNBC, that their money is safe and that Binance will cover every loss. The exchange suspended deposits and withdrawals while it worked through the freezes. That promise rests on the exchange’s balance sheet and on a reserve we covered in our report on Binance’s loss reserve.
The pledge changes the incentives. Customers are whole in theory, so pressure shifts to the exchange’s shareholders and its ability to rebuild trust. Every dollar of stablecoin frozen by Tether or Circle is a dollar Binance can try to recover, so the freeze totals bear directly on how large its final bill turns out to be.
The Policy Debate: Freeze Power Versus Knee-Jerk Rules
CNBC quoted two industry voices on the policy fallout. Frank Downing of Ark Invest urged regulators not to rush into more restrictive crypto policy. Chris Perkins of Franklin Crypto said investigators should concentrate on the offenders and not the victims. Both comments read as a pre-emptive defense of an industry that expects scrutiny.
The freeze response hands both sides a talking point. Supporters of stablecoin regulation can point to $2.7 billion to $2.84 billion pulled out of the attacker’s reach in hours. Critics of centralization can point out that a handful of firms decided which wallets lost access, with no court order mentioned in any report we reviewed. Both readings hold up, which is why the debate will not end quickly.
Competitive Comparison: How the Freezers Stack Up
Tether carried the largest dollar share, anywhere from $1.18 billion to $1.77 billion depending on the tracker, because USDT made up most of the stablecoins taken. Circle’s roughly $825 million in USDC came three minutes after Tether acted in Elliptic’s timeline. Ripple froze 40.5 million of the 88.5 million RLUSD taken, per TRM, and World Liberty Financial froze 27.8 million USD1.
The smaller freezes still carry weight. Partial coverage shows that not every issuer reached every stolen token in time, and the Arbitrum Security Council’s emergency move of about $30 million shows a governance body can act on a chain too. The common thread is that centralized switches did the work. Native ETH and BTC offered no such switch, and the attacker kept them.
What Exchange Security Teams Should Take Away
First, treat engineer workstations as tier-one assets. CNBC’s account of a compromised DevOps laptop echoes a long run of social-engineering cases. Second, cap what a single batch of signatures can move, since 50 pre-signed authorizations emptied wallets in one go. Third, review every delegation feature, including EIP-7702, as an approval path that needs the same controls as any other.
Fourth, rehearse the freeze call. The 37-minute gap before Tether acted shows how much depends on whether the right contact is reachable and the evidence is ready. Exchanges that keep pre-agreed escalation paths with issuers will save minutes that translate directly into dollars. For more security coverage, see our cybersecurity section.
Five Predictions for the Next Two Weeks
These are our analysis, not reported facts.
- An official attribution is likely. The FBI took five days at Bybit. With the Bitget link already documented, a formal statement within a few weeks looks probable.
- Binance will publish a root-cause report. TRM notes none exists yet, and the exchange needs one to back its loss pledge.
- The Bitcoin will start to move. Splitting 18,270 BTC across 19 addresses is preparation, and the first transfers to a service will become a major tracking moment.
- Issuers will publish freeze policies. The scale of this event will push Tether, Circle and others to explain when and why they act.
- Hot wallet controls will tighten. Expect exchanges to announce limits on batch signing and delegation reviews in the coming weeks.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much was stolen in the Binance hack? Binance says $6.3 billion. TRM Labs counts $6.36 billion and Elliptic $6.43 billion. All three agree it is the largest crypto theft on record.
How much has been frozen? Elliptic verified $2.84 billion, about 44% of the total. TRM Labs counts about $2.7 billion. Binance itself cites roughly $3 billion, a figure that overlaps with issuer freezes.
Who is responsible? No government has made an official attribution. Elliptic and TRM Labs point to North Korea-linked actors, with TRM naming TraderTraitor, but the identity of the attackers remains unconfirmed.
How did the attackers get in? CNBC reports a compromised DevOps engineer’s laptop as the initial breach source. Binance later said there were additional points of breach, and the full root cause has not been published.
Will Binance users lose money? Binance says user funds are safe and that it will cover all losses, according to CNBC. The exchange suspended deposits and withdrawals during its response.
Why can some stolen funds be frozen and others not? Stablecoin issuers such as Tether and Circle control smart contracts that can block specific addresses. Native assets like Bitcoin and Ether have no issuer, so no one can freeze them at the protocol level.
How does this compare with the Bybit hack? Bybit lost about $1.46 billion to $1.5 billion in February 2025. The Binance theft is roughly four times larger, and the FBI attributed Bybit to North Korea within five days, which has not happened here yet.
What happened to Bitcoin’s price? CNBC reported Bitcoin falling below $78,000 after the news, with Circle shares down more than 5% in early trading.